Is the Nara Baby app affected by the formula recall?

The app itself is not a recalled product and it still works. It is, however, made by the same company. Nara Organics founder Esther Hallam built the Nara Baby tracker years before the formula existed, and the app grew to roughly 1.5 million parents, which is the audience the formula business was later built on. If you use the app, nothing about your phone is unsafe. It is worth knowing whose business your baby's data sits inside.

Is the Nara Baby app still free?

No. Nara Baby now costs $9.99 a month or $99.99 for lifetime access, after a 7-day free trial that starts when you log your first entry. That change landed before the June 2026 formula recall, so the recall did not cause it, but it does mean the app parents recommended for years as the free one is no longer free.

What should I do if I still have Nara formula at home?

Do not feed it to your baby, even if the can looks and smells fine. Nara automatically refunded website orders placed in May and June 2026, and other customers can request a refund through the company's form or return cans to Target. Watch your baby for constipation, a weak cry, poor feeding, droopy eyelids, or a floppy, weak body, and get medical care immediately if you see them. Infant botulism is treatable, and treatment works best when it starts early.

Nara's Formula Recall and the App That Was Never Really Free

Q: Which Nara formula was recalled?

On June 13, 2026, Nara Organics recalled every lot and both can sizes of Nara Organics Whole Milk Organic Powdered Infant Formula because of possible Clostridium botulinum contamination. It had been sold nationwide between July 2025 and June 2026 at Target stores, Target.com and Nara.com. Four infants in California, Pennsylvania and Washington were hospitalized with infant botulism. There were no reported deaths, and the CDC declared the outbreak over in late August 2026.

Q: Is Nara formula coming back?

Nara announced on August 27, 2026 that it plans to sell infant formula in the United States again, using a fully European dairy supply chain and new testing designed to detect C. botulinum. Its German manufacturer was added to an FDA import alert after an inspection found serious deviations from infant formula requirements. As of September 2026 the product is not back on shelves.

Last November, when ByHeart pulled every can of its infant formula off the shelves in a botulism outbreak, a lot of frightened parents went looking for a different brand. Nara Organics put up a page to help them. It said, and I am quoting it exactly: "Please be assured that Nara Organics is not affected by this recall and our formula is safe to drink."

Seven months later, Nara recalled every can of formula it had ever sold. Botulism.

If Nara has been showing up in your feed and you could not quite piece together what happened, here is the whole thing. Including the part most of the coverage skips, which is that the very good, very popular, very free baby tracking app on a million and a half phones belongs to the same company.

TL;DR: Nara Organics recalled all of its infant formula in June 2026 after four babies were hospitalized with botulism. No deaths, and the outbreak is over. The Nara Baby app is made by that same company, was free for years because the formula was the actual business, and now costs $9.99 a month or $99.99 for life. Your app and your baby's data always ride on somebody's business model. This is what it looks like when that model has a very bad year.

What actually happened with the Nara formula recall

Nara Organics was founded in 2018 in New York by Esther Hallam, who could not find an infant formula she was happy with. The formula took years to get to market. It was USDA organic, made with whole milk fat instead of skim, manufactured in Germany, and it arrived with genuinely good press.

July 2025 Nara formula goes on sale in the US.
November 2025 ByHeart recalls all of its formula in a botulism outbreak that eventually sickens dozens of babies. Nara publishes a page reassuring worried parents that its own formula is safe.
January 2026 Nara launches nationwide at Target, its first retail rollout.
April and May 2026 Babies start getting sick. Nobody connects it yet.
June 12, 2026 The FDA and CDC contact Nara about three infants with botulism who drank its formula.
June 13, 2026 Nara recalls every lot and both can sizes of its Whole Milk Organic Powdered Infant Formula for possible Clostridium botulinum contamination.
June 22, 2026 The first lawsuit is filed in Pennsylvania. More follow, including against Target for selling it.
July 2026 A fourth case is confirmed. All four babies are boys between two and five months old, from California, Pennsylvania and Washington. All four were hospitalized and treated with BabyBIG, the botulism antitoxin. Unopened cans later test positive for C. botulinum. Nara's German manufacturer is added to an FDA import alert after an inspection finds serious deviations from infant formula requirements.
August 27, 2026 The CDC declares the outbreak over. The same day, Nara announces it intends to sell formula again, with a fully European dairy supply chain and new testing built specifically to catch C. botulinum.

Four babies, all hospitalized, none of them lost. That last part matters and it deserves to be said plainly rather than buried.

If you still have a can of Nara in the house

Do not feed it to your baby. Botulism spores do not change how powder looks, smells or tastes, so a normal-looking can tells you nothing.

Nara automatically refunded website orders from May and June 2026. For anything else, you can request a refund through the company's form or return it to Target. The FDA recall notice and Nara's recall page have the details.

Infant botulism usually starts with constipation, then a weak or different-sounding cry, poor feeding, droopy eyelids, less facial expression, trouble swallowing, and a floppy, weak body. If your baby has any of that, get medical care right away and say the word "botulism" and the word "formula" out loud. It is treatable, and treatment works best early. The CDC's outbreak page is the reference to keep.

Is the Nara Baby app part of this? Yes, and it came first

Here is what a lot of people reading the recall headlines did not realize. Before there was Nara formula, there was Nara Baby.

Hallam built the tracker first, in 2018, for the extremely relatable reason that she had a newborn and could not keep track of anything. It was clean, ad-free and free. Parents loved it. It was the app that got recommended in every Reddit thread where someone asked for a tracker that would not nag them for a subscription. It grew to about 1.5 million parents, almost entirely by word of mouth, while the formula was still years from a shelf.

None of that is a secret, by the way. Inc. wrote the story up under the headline "How This Founder Accidentally Created a Marketing Funnel of 1.5 Million Users." That is the company's own framing, in a business magazine, as a success story. And honestly, as a business move it is a great one. You build years of daily trust with exactly the people who will shortly be deciding what to pour into a bottle.

The app was free because the app was not the product. The relationship was the product, and the formula was what the relationship was for.

So when the formula got recalled, this was not a company having a bad quarter in a business unrelated to your phone. It was the same company. The one with your baby's feeding history in its cloud.

Is Nara Baby still free? No, and that changed before the recall

Worth getting the order of events right, because it is not the story you would assume. Nara Baby went paid before the recall, not after it. It now runs $9.99 a month or $99.99 for lifetime access, after a 7-day trial that starts when you log your first entry. The recall did not cause the paywall.

But it does leave parents in a strange spot. The free tracker everybody recommended is now $99.99. The reason it could be free for all those years is currently being sued, is rebuilding a supply chain across an ocean, and had its manufacturing plant flagged by the FDA. And the fee, per Nara's own explanation, is what funds the app's future.

I want to be fair here, because I think fairness makes the point better than dunking does. Nara recalled fast once federal officials called. No babies died. The app is genuinely well made and it is still ad-free. Moving to fully European sourcing with targeted C. botulinum testing is a real response, not a press release with nothing behind it. And formula is not the villain of this story. Formula feeds millions of babies safely every single day, including plenty in my own life, and a recall is an argument about one company's manufacturing, not about how you feed your kid.

Is Nara formula coming back?

Nara says yes. The August announcement laid out a fully European dairy supply chain (the company had already been moving off US dairy suppliers) plus new testing designed specifically to catch C. botulinum, which is not standard practice across the industry and would be a meaningful upgrade if it holds.

The counterweight, and food safety lawyers were quick to point it out, is what the announcement did not dwell on: the German plant that made the formula landed on an FDA import alert after inspectors found serious deviations from infant formula requirements, and the lawsuits are still moving. As of this writing there is no date and nothing back on a shelf. If you are waiting on Nara to come back, watch the FDA's investigation page rather than the company's, which is good advice for any recall.

Why this is bigger than Nara

Every free baby app is free because of something. There is always a something. Ads, data brokerage, venture money buying growth before the price goes up, an AI upsell waiting at month three, or a physical product the app exists to sell. "Free" is not a gift, it is a business model you have not read yet.

Chart of the four business models behind free baby tracking apps: ads, your data, investor money, and a physical product like infant formula — Four ways a free baby app gets paid for. Nara's was the fourth one, and it was never a secret.

Which is fine, right up until the something goes wrong. When the model is advertising, you get ads in your night feeds. When it is venture funding, you get the day the runway ends and the $99.99 lifetime plan appears. And when it is formula, you get a June like Nara's.

The useful question to ask about any app you let into the worst-slept year of your life is not "how much does it cost." It is "what is this app for, from the other side of the screen?" A tracker that sells you a subscription wants you logging forever. A tracker attached to a product wants you buying. That shapes the notifications you get, the data that is worth collecting, and what happens to all of it if the company has a bad year or gets acquired.

I write about this a lot, probably too much, in why most breastfeeding apps do too much. This month is just the loudest possible example.

What I would actually do

Not a dramatic call to delete anything. Three honest options:

You like Nara and $99.99 once feels fair. Then keep it. It covers every caregiver in your family, it tracks everything, and it works on Android. That is a real product at a real price, and the company being in a hard year does not make the tracker worse at tracking.
You want out. Export your data before you cancel anything, not after. Check what the company says it does with your account data when you leave, which is a question worth asking of every app, not just this one.
You mostly just wanted a feeding timer anyway. That is most people, honestly. You do not need a dashboard, you need to know which side and how long ago.

That third one is what I built. MilkMode is a breastfeeding timer and nothing else. One tap from a Home Screen widget, left and right side tracking, a Live Activity on your Lock Screen so you can see the running timer at 3am without unlocking anything. No account, no cloud, no sync. Your feeding data sits on your phone and never goes anywhere, including to me, because there is no server for it to go to. It costs $4.99 one time after a 7-day trial.

MilkMode Home Screen widget with left and right breast buttons for starting a feed without opening the app — Start a feed straight from the Home Screen widget, or run it in the app in dark mode at 3am. No account, no cloud, nothing syncing anywhere.

MilkMode breastfeeding timer in dark mode running a feed on the left side during a night feed — Start a feed straight from the Home Screen widget, or run it in the app in dark mode at 3am. No account, no cloud, nothing syncing anywhere.

The honest limits, since this whole post is about reading the fine print: it is iPhone only, it does not track diapers or sleep or pumping, and it will not sync to your partner's phone. If you need those things, it is the wrong app and I would rather you knew that now. Our roundup of timer apps covers the alternatives, including where mine loses.

The bottom line

I am obviously not a neutral party. I make a competing app and I charge $4.99 once, so of course I think that is the better deal. But the reason I built it that way is the reason this story got under my skin: I did not want there to be a second business behind the first one. There is no formula to sell you, no data to resell, no round to raise, and no scenario where something happening in another division changes what is on your phone. You pay five dollars, you get a timer, we are done.

Four families spent part of this year in a hospital with a baby on an antitoxin drip, and I would not trade a single download for that. But the lesson sitting in the middle of it is one worth carrying to whatever app you pick next: know what the thing is for. Somebody built it for a reason, and if it is free, the reason is not you.

If you want the full app-by-app breakdown, I keep an updated comparison at MilkMode vs. Nara Baby, and a look at how Nara stacks up against the big subscription trackers in Nara Baby vs. Huckleberry.

Common questions

Which Nara formula was recalled? Every lot and both can sizes of Nara Organics Whole Milk Organic Powdered Infant Formula, recalled June 13, 2026 over possible Clostridium botulinum contamination. It was sold nationwide from July 2025 to June 2026 at Target, Target.com and Nara.com.

Is the Nara Baby app affected by the recall? The app is not a recalled product and it still works normally. It is made by the same company, which is the part worth knowing. Nothing about having it on your phone is unsafe.

Is Nara Baby still free? No. It is $9.99 a month or $99.99 for lifetime access after a 7-day trial that starts when you log your first entry. That change came before the recall.

What do I do with a can I already have? Do not use it. Nara auto-refunded website orders from May and June 2026, other purchases can be refunded through the company's form, and Target cans can go back to Target. Watch for constipation, weak cry, poor feeding, droopy eyelids or floppiness, and get care immediately if you see them.

Is Nara formula coming back? The company says it plans to return with European sourcing and new C. botulinum testing. There is no date yet and nothing is back on shelves as of September 2026.

Keep reading

Try MilkMode free for 7 days

No ads. No account. No data leaving your phone. Nothing else to sell you.

Download on the App Store